Kids And Screen Time: Cutting Through The Static

Sep 30, 2014
Originally published on September 30, 2014 1:46 pm

The walls are lined with robots and movie posters for Star Wars and Back to the Future. But this is no 1980s nerd den. It's the technology lab at Westside Neighborhood School in Los Angeles, and the domain of its ed-tech coordinator, Don Fitz-Roy.

"So we're gonna be talking about digital citizenship today."

Fitz-Roy is a mountain of a man, bald with just the hint of a goatee. Of the half-dozen students sitting in small, plastic chairs around him, any three could easily fit inside his shirt. And he's trying to keep them safe — from the Internet.

He's talking about the laundry list of athletes and actors these kids have seen, of late, making fools of themselves using social media.

He tells the students: "They say something online, and then suddenly they say, 'I'm gonna delete this. No, I changed my mind.' They didn't mean to say that. And it's out there."

This class is just one example of WNS' pretty radical technology policy — a policy that has second- and third-graders not just typing, but doing Internet research and computer programming.

Here's the challenge: Much of it requires screen time.

The Screen-Time Experiment

And, with so much talk these days of bad screen time, what is good screen time? It's a question that perplexes parents and educators alike.

We've heard the arguments, the warnings, the prescriptions. The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends that kids' entertainment screen time be limited "to less than one or two hours per day." And for kids under 2: none at all.

We recently reported on a study out of the University of California, Los Angeles. The short of it: Researchers found that sixth-graders who spent just five days at an outdoor camp, away from their electronic devices, improved remarkably at reading emotion in other people's faces.

The experiment comes with lots of caveats. It was small (roughly 100 kids). And removing screens from the equation did not, by itself, improve these kids' social skills. What likely led to the improvement was the fact that, instead of texting or gaming, the students were working together, face-to-face, constantly decoding each other's expressions, voice tone and posture.

The take-home: Social skills require constant maintenance.

The good news, according to this study, is that we can improve those skills in relatively short order, with practice. The bad news is that screen time often comes at the expense of that vital face-to-face time.

Which is why what's happening at one independent school in Los Angeles is so interesting.

Westside Neighborhood School

With kids from pre-K through 8th grade, WNS sits tucked into the shadow of a Home Depot in L.A.'s booming Playa Vista neighborhood. It's close enough to the ocean that the air is more salt than smog.

When talking about screen time and kids' access to handheld devices, Brad Zacuto, who heads the school, likes to use an old-fashioned analogy: "It's like putting a child behind a wheel of a car. There's a lot of power there."

Think about how dangerous it was back when cars first hit the road, Zacuto says. No traffic lights or street signs. That's where we are now, he warns, with kids and all this technology at their fingertips. "It's here to stay. But at some point you have to teach kids how to drive a car responsibly."

Zacuto's tech policy begins with a few basics:

First, no smartphones till sixth grade. Even then, kids can bring them, but they have to check them at the front desk.

Second, engaging and educating parents: WNS makes them sign a commitment to limit screen time at home and to keep kids off of social media — again, until sixth grade.

Also, at school, no technology until second grade. "We choose to have our youngest children engaged in digging in dirt," Zacuto says, "and building things and using their hands."

Not just their hands but their eyeballs and brains, too: interacting with other kids face to face. Because they need lots of early practice relating, reading emotion and responding to it.

In second grade, Zacuto says, kids start using classroom laptops. They get some basic lessons in typing and word processing and their first taste of Internet research.

Which makes this a good time to go back to that tech lab and Don Fitz-Roy.

'Star Wars Kid'

The idea behind Fitz-Roy's digital citizenship class is to get kids thinking hard about the dangers of social media before they have Twitter handles or Facebook pages.

The kids gathered for today's conversation are a little older than usual and have heard much of this before.

Thirteen-year-old Tom Zimmerman gets it: "One example: this one kid who was, like, in this room, and he had, like, this fake lightsaber, and he was acting really crazy. And it looked really stupid. And it was funny, but I'm sure that kid won't want it in the future. But so many people have taken that video and put it on their channels that there's no way of getting rid of it."

That 2002 video — of one teen boy in a heated lightsaber battle with himself --has been watched millions of times, but the so-called "Star Wars Kid," now in his 20s, says he was bullied because of it and had to leave school.

And that gives principals like Brad Zacuto not one but two big reasons to worry about screen time: 1) Because of what's not happening — important face-to-face time; and 2) Because of what is happening — kids putting themselves out there in embarrassing and potentially dangerous ways.

Which, again, raises the question:

What Is Good Screen Time?

"It's all about how things are used. And how much they're used. And what they're used for," says Patricia Greenfield, who co-authored that screen-time study we mentioned earlier. She's a professor of psychology at UCLA and has been writing about screen time for 30 years.

Greenfield offers this example of good screen time: asking kids to write an essay using the computer. Word-processing software can help with spelling and grammar, and kids can use the Internet for research. Here's the key:

"You're not substituting screen time for interaction time," Greenfield says. "You're substituting alone time with the screen for alone time with your paper and pen."

Greenfield describes a kind of cost-benefit analysis: Is this screen time coming at the expense of face-to-face time? And what unique value does the technology add?

At Westside Neighborhood School, when kids use tech, they're often still working collaboratively — and doing things they couldn't do without it.

"We have a design class where they imagine a product," Zacuto says. "They design it. And we have a 3-D printer where they then create it. I mean, there's amazing things going on that's preparing them for the world."

Preparing Them For The World

By sixth grade, WNS students may have to check their smartphones at the door, but they get their own school-issued tablets with textbooks on them. Still, Zacuto insists, little valuable class time is spent simply looking down.

When sixth-grade social studies teacher Caitlin Barry gives her students time to read from the textbooks on their iPads, they often do it in pairs, encouraging each other to explore confusing terms or ideas. Some teachers even put short lectures online, for students to watch at home. The reason goes back to Greenfield's cost-benefit analysis:

"It sort of flips the content," Zacuto says. "I'd rather be spending my time in school with the teacher, with the kids — doing interactive, collaborative [things], using what we've learned."

In other words: using screens at home to increase the time students spend working face to face in the classroom. It's a delicate dance, preparing kids for both the Digital Age and the social world.

And it's important not to sacrifice the latter for the former, says Yalda Uhls, who is a senior researcher at the Children's Digital Media Center@LA and co-author of the screen-time study with Patricia Greenfield. Especially in middle school, she says, when the balance of power in kids' lives tilts away from their parents and toward friends.

"One of the reasons it's so miserable," Uhls says, "is because we're trying to learn our place in the social world outside of our safe little haven at home."

The more practice kids get reading emotion in voices and posture, the better they'll be able to navigate the turmoil of early adolescence.

That kind of social learning just won't fit in the palm of your hand.

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit


A recent experiment by researchers at UCLA found that sixth-graders in their study averaged about four-and-a-half hours a day of screen time outside of school - on laptops, smartphones, iPads, TVs. But that's not the headline; the headline is what happened to the kids when they had their screens taken away. From the NPR Education Team, Corey Turner explains.

COREY TURNER, BYLINE: The whole thing started with one simple question...

YALDA UHLS: What if we created an experiment where kids stop staring at screens and they stared at faces? They looked at people. You know, what would happen to their social skills?

TURNER: Yalda Uhls was lead author of the study and a senior researcher at the Children's Digital Media Center at Los Angeles. She took two groups of sixth-graders. One was told, live your lives, go to school, text and watch TV and play video games as much as you want. The other group was sent to an outdoor camp in the California Mountains, five days, no electronic devices. At the start of the week and again at the end, both groups were given a pair of tests to measure how well they pick up on someone else's emotions. The first test involved quickly showing the students photographs.

UHLS: Adult faces and kids' faces, high and low intensity of four emotions. And we asked the kids to identify the emotion.

TURNER: Happiness, fear, anger or sadness. The kids also watched videos of staged scenes - someone gets a sweater they don't like and has to fake a thank you; in another, two young actors gossip. Since the dialogue would give away the emotions, the sound has been garbled, like a "Peanuts" cartoon.


UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER #1: (Unintelligible).

TURNER: What happened? Again, researcher Yalda Uhls.

UHLS: We found that in just five days, kids who were at the camp got significantly better at recognizing emotion than the kids who were at school.

TURNER: Those results raised some serious red flags about kids' technology consumption, especially when so much of their screen time is spent texting. Patricia Greenfield, co-author of the study with Uhls, is director of the Children's Digital Media Center at Los Angeles.

PATRICIA GREENFIELD: Interacting with other people by text does not develop your social skills. You have to be around people and be interacting in person.

TURNER: Before you rush your kids off to a mountain retreat, some caveats - the experiment was small, roughly 100 students, and again it was just five days. Also cutting out screen time probably won't by itself improve anybody's social skills. The camp kids showed improvement not just because they cut out the screen time, but because they replaced it with face-to-face time, working with and relating to their classmates. And lest you think the study's lead author, Yalda Uhls, is some kind of anti-tech crusader...

UHLS: I used to be a senior vice president at MGM making movies. I love movies, but there needs to be a balance.

TURNER: For parents, the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends capping screen time at two hours a day for kids three and older. But finding that balance gets trickier if you're a school principal because not all screen time is spent texting or playing video games; some of it's good.

BRAD ZACUTO: We have a design class where they imagine product, they design it and we have a 3-D printer where they then create it. I mean, there's amazing things going on that's preparing them for the world they're going into. That's how things are going to happen.

TURNER: That's Brad Zacuto, head of Westside Neighborhood School in Los Angeles. Later today on All Things Considered, I'll have the story of Zacuto's pretty radical technology policy. He takes kids' smartphones at the door, but gives them iPads in class. Corey Turner, NPR News, Washington. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.