For China's Overburdened Delivery Workers, The Customer — And App — Is Always Right

Dec 1, 2020
Originally published on December 2, 2020 8:04 am

Zhang was the picture of despair the first time I met him.

He had accidentally delivered a package to a neighbor of mine who took it and would not give it back. Now, trembling, he wanted to personally reimburse me for the lost item.

I refused to take his money, but for two days, he called me nonstop to apologize. At the time, I did not understand why he was so repentant. Then I found out how closely monitored — and severely punished — delivery workers like him are.

"Customers complain, and after multiple complaints, we get fined very heavily," says Zhang. NPR spoke with nearly a dozen delivery workers in Beijing for this story and agreed to use only surnames, because the workers could be punished for talking to a reporter.

The delivery workers described grueling routines: 12-hour days, six days a week, under the automated and watchful eye of mobile apps that track how and when they deliver hundreds of packages a day.

Delivery workers are a critical link in China's on-demand courier services, which ship more than 60 billion packages a year and generate nearly 1% of the country's annual economic activity.

Yet even as booming e-commerce platforms result in higher numbers of packages delivered each day, courier services are cutting the fees they pay delivery workers per package delivered. Five Chinese delivery workers told NPR their per-package fees had dropped by an average of 25% in the past year.

"Rewards are light" and punishments "heavy"

China's more than 3 million delivery workers are a ubiquitous sight on city streets, zipping around haphazardly on scooters and auto rickshaws. They ensure that a food takeout order can arrive in minutes; an online purchase, the same day.

But there is a dark side to this ultraconvenient service.

Their performance is evaluated by mobile apps on phones that the courier services give workers — these delivery logistics apps track their deliveries, sometimes deducting hundreds of dollars in penalties from monthly compensation that averages below $800.

"The rewards are light, but the punishments are always heavy," says a delivery worker named Wang who works for Zhongtong, one of China's largest courier services.

Good customer reviews earn delivery workers virtual points in the app, which serve as a buffer against deductions. In the case of a late package or a three-out-of-five-star review, the app will knock off points. Too few points, and a worker gets fined.

If Wang fails to garner at least one five-star review a month, he gets slapped with an $8 pay deduction. If someone complains by email, Wang is fined about $300, nearly a week's wages. Lesser offenses can carry fines of about $30 to $80.

"On those days, it is as if I worked the entire day, delivering 400 packages, for nothing," he says.

In China, customers are provided the delivery worker's mobile number for each package they order, giving the recipient a direct and highly personal link to monitor — or heckle — delivery workers.

"Many clients really like to make life difficult. They will call just to make you walk up 11 flights of stairs or to criticize you for not delivering their package to their door that very day," says Zhang, the delivery worker in my compound.

Yet he remains unfailingly polite on such calls. Display even a trace of anger to a customer and "they threaten to report you," says Zhang. He faces a $300 fine for such complaints.

Disputing those fines is nearly impossible — that's why Zhang was so scared when he lost my package, fearing I would report him.

"Always our mistake"

Zhang allowed me to tag along on a delivery run in November. He drives a three-wheeled cart of sorts more than an hour into central Beijing to deliver to my compound.

His route that day was relaxed — only about 60 packages to deliver. On most days he has about 200. I still struggled to keep up with the 21-year-old's hurried stride.

Zhang works for a smaller courier service that contracts with China's five biggest delivery platforms – each multibillion-dollar listed companies whose founders are among China's richest men. By contrast, delivery workers like Zhang earn only 15 to 30 cents per package.

Yet they are the crucial, last-mile step and the only customer-facing link in the logistics supply chain, meaning they are faulted for mistakes or delays that happen at any point along the way.

"Misplace a package because the customer wrote the address wrong? That does not matter — it is always our mistake," says Zhang.

Smudged packaging labels and vague addresses are the biggest source of delivery delays that diminish his monthly compensation, he says. Some clients have reported him for packages he delivered with items missing — because the e-commerce store never packed them.

Then there are the more arbitrary rules Zhang has to remember. For example, he is not paid for packages delivered outside the preferred time window. Customers who sign up for his employer's VIP courier service must be called when their package is delivered; Zhang's mobile app tracks whether he makes the calls and fines him $8 if he does not.

There have been a few dozen strikes this year by delivery workers fed up with unpaid or declining wages. In early September, Zhongtong delivery employees in Hubei province collectively resigned after the delivery fee they were paid per package was cut several times. Other Zhongtong employees staged a protest for unpaid wages dating back half a year. Employees at Yunda, another of China's largest courier services, left thousands of packages piled up in a walkout over unpaid salaries in June.

Food delivery workers at the popular Alibaba-owned Ele.me and Meituan services have staged multiple protests this year over low pay and dangerously rushed delivery routes. Meituan and Alibaba later introduced a new feature that lets customers tip their delivery workers — which prompted criticism from customers who were angry the financial burden was shifting to them.

Because delivery workers are considered temporary employees, they are not represented by China's state union, nor can they organize on their own.

Meanwhile, Chinese consumers are buying more stuff online than ever — and they want it instantaneously. And for every delivery worker who quits, there is another waiting to take his place.

Amy Cheng contributed research from Beijing.

Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:

Worldwide, the pandemic has moved lots more shopping online. In China these days, consumers not only order goods with a click. They expect to get them almost as fast. But as NPR's Emily Feng reports from Beijing, there is a dark side to this ultra-convenient service.

EMILY FENG, BYLINE: Zhang was the picture of despair the first time I met him. He'd accidentally given my package to a neighbor who took it and wouldn't give it back. Now a trembling Zhang wanted to personally pay me back for the lost item. I wouldn't take his money, but he called me non-stop for two days to apologize. I didn't understand why he was so repentant. Then Zhang explained.

ZHANG: (Through interpreter) Customers complain, and after multiple complaints, we get fined very heavily.

FENG: Delivery services have mobile apps that track how many packages each worker drops off and when. Good reviews earn delivery workers virtual points in the app. But a late package or a three-out-of-five-star review - the app will deduct points.

(SOUNDBITE OF TRAFFIC PASSING)

FENG: Delivery workers are literally everywhere on Chinese urban streets these days. I'm standing on a Beijing street corner right now, and I'm jostling for space with tricycles and scooters manned by courier delivery workers. We spoke to nearly a dozen of these workers. They described grueling routines - 12-hour days, six days a week, always afraid their pay will be arbitrarily docked. Zhang allowed me to tag along on a delivery run this month, but we agreed to use only his last name because he could be punished for speaking to a reporter on the job.

ZHANG: (Non-English language spoken).

FENG: Today is pretty relaxed - only about 60 packages to deliver. On most days, he's got about 200. I still struggle to keep up with the 21-year-old's hurried stride.

Faster, faster.

Delivery services account for almost 1% of China's entire annual GDP. Workers like Zhang delivered more than 60 billion packages last year. They only receive 15 to 30 cents per package, yet they're the crucial last-mile step and the only customer-facing link in the logistics supply chain. In China, customers can call their delivery man directly.

ZHANG: (Through interpreter) Many clients really like to make life difficult. They'll call just to make you walk up 11 flights of stairs or to criticize you for not delivering their package that day. Then they threaten to report you.

FENG: And being reported carries fines of up to 2,000 RMB or about $300, equivalent to a week's wages on a good week. Disputing the fines is nearly impossible. That's why Zhang was so scared when he lost my package.

ZHANG: (Through interpreter) We're fined the equivalent of the lost package's worth. Even if it's because people write the wrong address, it's still our mistake when we don't deliver.

FENG: Then there are the rules Zhang has to remember, all while running upstairs with an armload of packages.

ZHANG: (Through interpreter) You're not paid at all if you deliver a package outside the requested time window. And the other day, I forgot to call two VIP clients after I delivered their packages. My mobile app then alerted me that I had been fined about half my pay that day.

FENG: Some delivery workers have gone on strike this year, fed up with unpaid or diminishing wages. Their employers have cut salaries even as revenue grows because of booming demand.

ZHANG: (Non-English language spoken).

FENG: But Zhang says delivery work is a step up from his last job as a cook, which he left because the dirty kitchen conditions there gave him acne. Zhang now lives in a dormitory to save money for a future apartment, but he'd like to get a better job and learn a new skill. And when Zhang does quit, there's sure to be another delivery man to take his place, ready to cater to Chinese consumers who are buying more and more goods online and want them ASAP.

Emily Feng, NPR News, Beijing.

(SOUNDBITE OF KYLE DIXON AND MICHAEL STEIN'S "KIDS") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.